Florida men convicted in Highland County aggravated theft case
The Highland County Sheriff's Office has concluded an investigation into a financial scam that resulted in a Highland County resident losing approximately $19,000.
The investigation began Dec. 1, 2025, when deputies responded to a residence in Brushcreek Township after the victim reported being scammed by individuals impersonating representatives of an area bank’s fraud department.
Investigators learned that the victim had been convinced that his bank accounts were compromised and instructed to withdraw his money to protect it. After withdrawing a total of $19,000 from banks in Winchester and Hillsboro, the victim was instructed that a federal agent would come to his residence to collect the money.
On Nov. 27, 2025, an individual arrived at the victim's residence in a black Toyota SUV and retrieved the cash. Through investigative leads, investigators identified the driver, who had unknowingly been contracted to transport the money as part of what he believed was a legitimate delivery. Additional evidence was obtained through vehicle video, hotel records, airline records and airport surveillance footage.
With assistance from the Milford Police Department, CVG Airport, and the Hamilton County Heroin Task Force, investigators identified the suspects as Leon Raynard Brown and Cecil Silvester Arnold, both from Locka, Fla.
A Highland County grand jury indicted both suspects, and they were extradited from Florida back to Highland County. On Nov. 5, both suspects pleaded guilty in Highland County Common Pleas Court to felony 3 aggravated theft from a person in a protected class by deception. Both were sentenced to 12 months in prison and ordered to pay restitution.
The Highland County Sheriff's Office reminds residents that financial institutions and government agencies will never ask customers to withdraw large sums of cash and turn it over to an unknown individual or purchase gift cards to resolve fraudulent account activity. Anyone who receives such requests should immediately stop communicating and contact their financial institution directly.
The Sheriff's Office appreciates the cooperation and assistance of all agencies and individuals who contributed to this investigation.